Blogs From Piranha Profits™

Understanding Covered Puts and its Risks

Written by Piranha Profits Team | Aug 18, 2025 4:58:52 AM

Assuming you've done your homework and firmly believe a stock is heading downward. You're confident in your analysis, but you’d like to generate some additional income while waiting for the decline to unfold. Some traders might consider selling Covered Puts. 

When traders first encounter covered puts, they're often expanding their horizons beyond familiar strategies like covered calls. Questions arise: How do covered puts differ from similarly named strategies such as cash-secured puts? Can this strategy genuinely help generate income in bearish or sideways markets? There's frequent confusion, too—some mistakenly view covered puts as conservative moves, similar to selling puts to acquire shares. 

This article will clear up these misunderstandings, outline critical differences, and help you understand how covered puts works. 

Understanding the Covered Put Strategy

A covered put involves two primary actions:

  1. Shorting 100 shares of a stock you anticipate will decline.

  2. Selling a put option against those same shares, typically at-the-money (ATM) or slightly out-of-the-money (OTM).

When you short the shares first, you're establishing a clear bearish position, and this does not change from the covered put you are selling. Selling the put generates immediate premium income, reducing the effective cost basis of your short stock position. Ideally, if the stock stays flat or moderately declines, you stand to profit. However, if the stock unexpectedly rises, the short position will lead to substantial, theoretically unlimited losses.

Real-World Example of a Covered Put

Let’s illustrate with a practical scenario. Consider a stock currently trading at $50:

Possible Outcomes:

  • Stock drops to $43: You earn $7 per share from your short position but lose $2 per share on the put option, as you must buy the stock at the $45 strike. Your total gain combines to $7 per share, including your initial premium.

  • Stock remains at $50: The short position remains neutral, but you retain the $2 premium per share—a straightforward profit.

  • Stock rises to $55: Your short position incurs a $5 per share loss, but the put premium ($2 per share) cushions the blow slightly, resulting in a net loss of $3 per share.

 

Why Covered Puts are Rarely used 

A covered put may sound like a smart bearish play, but it’s often a self-defeating strategy with an unfavorable risk-reward profile. By selling the put, you’re capping the very downside profits that make a short stock position attractive in the first place. 

If the stock collapses, your short put forces you to buy it back at the strike price, cutting off your gains. Meanwhile, the upside risk remains unlimited, if the stock rallies, both legs of the position lose. 

Traders who use covered puts typically aren’t expecting a huge drop; they’re often already short the stock and sell puts to collect small premiums while waiting for a slow grind lower. It’s a niche strategy used more for income generation or margin structuring than outright speculation.

Advantages of Using Covered Puts

Immediate Premium Income

Selling a put option instantly generates premium income. This effectively reduces your short position's breakeven point and offers some cushioning against minor upward price movements.

Profitable in Neutral and Bearish Markets

Covered puts can significantly maximise returns in bearish or range-bound markets. They can profit when stock prices stagnate or decline moderately, helping traders generate consistent returns in uncertain conditions.

 

Risks to Seriously Consider When Selling Covered Puts

 

Unlimited Upside Risk

The primary danger of the covered put strategy is the potential for unlimited losses if the stock price rises substantially. Unlike buying shares, shorting exposes traders to infinite risk because stocks theoretically have no upper price limit.

High Margin Requirements and Complexity

Brokerages impose strict margin requirements due to the high risks associated with shorting. Additionally, simultaneously managing both a short stock position and a put option can be complex, requiring diligent monitoring, precise execution, and a robust understanding of how markets behave under various conditions.

Unsuitable for Beginners

Shorting stocks directly opposes traditional market momentum. This contrarian approach requires a deep understanding of market dynamics and technical indicators. Beginners typically lack the experience necessary to manage such high-risk trades effectively.

Bear Market Volatility

Bear markets are typically characterized by heightened volatility. Stocks can drop dramatically and unpredictably, then recover rapidly. Betting on a dip using strategies like the covered put requires extreme discipline and tight control over your position to avoid catastrophic losses.



Covered Put and Cash-Secured Put: Clearing Up the Confusion

A common confusion among traders involves differentiating covered puts from cash-secured puts. While both involve selling put options, their intentions and risk profiles are distinct:

  • Covered Put: You short shares first, then sell put options against this short position. It’s a bearish strategy with unlimited risk, usually when you expect stable or declining stock prices.

  • Cash-Secured Put: You sell put options without holding an existing short position, securing the obligation with cash. This strategy is neutral to bullish, focusing on acquiring shares at a discount and carries limited risk defined by the cash reserved. This is typically an investor strategy used to acquire good companies at a lower price while also being paid to wait.

While the two might sound similar, their directional biases significantly differ. Traders typically use covered puts to generate premium income while anticipating stock price declines. In contrast, cash-secured puts are more conservative, serving as a method to enter quality stocks at a desired price, somewhat like placing a limit order.

Risk Management For Covered Puts

Unlike defined-risk strategies, covered puts expose traders to potentially catastrophic losses if not handled with care. Here are several vital measures every trader should consider:

  • Define Entry and Exit Points: Before initiating a trade, have a clear plan for where you will enter and exit both the short stock and the put option legs. This includes price levels at which you’ll cut losses or lock in profits. Without predetermined levels, emotion-driven decisions can quickly derail your strategy.

  • Use Stop-Loss Orders: A properly placed stop-loss on your short stock can prevent exponential losses if the stock unexpectedly rallies. This is especially important in markets where short squeezes or news-driven surges can occur rapidly.

  • Monitor Fundamentals and Sentiment: Staying informed about the company’s news, earnings dates, and broader market conditions can help you avoid surprises. Bearish trades can implode quickly if market sentiment shifts unexpectedly or if the company releases strong results.

  • Avoid Illiquid Names: Illiquid stocks not only have wider spreads but also tend to be more vulnerable to sharp upside spikes, which can wreak havoc on your short position.

 

Alternatives to Covered Puts

If you hold a short term bearish outlook but prefer strategies with more clearly defined risk, consider options like the bear put spread, which involves buying a higher strike put and selling a lower strike put. Unlike covered puts, bear put spreads do not require holding a risky short stock position and limit your maximum potential loss to the premium paid, providing controlled exposure in bearish market scenarios.

Traders who still wish to utilize covered puts may choose to pair the strategy with a long call option, creating a hedge against large upward movements and effectively capping the potential losses, providing greater peace of mind in volatile market conditions.

 

Final Thoughts

Covered puts, while sophisticated and potentially profitable, require deep market understanding and strict discipline due to their significant risks. Always prioritize rigorous analysis, disciplined execution, and proactive risk management to ensure success and long-term profitability. If you are new to options trading, we strongly recommend against selling covered puts.