When traders first explore options with defined risk, they often find themselves choosing between two foundational tactics: Covered Calls and Protective Puts. Both aim to balance profit potential with downside protection.
When you combine both strategies tactically, you create a strategy known as the collar. A powerful way to define both your upside and downside risks .
Income with a Ceiling : The Covered Call Strategy
A covered call is when you sell a call option on a stock you already own to earn extra income, while agreeing to sell the stock at a set price if it rises too much. By doing this, you collect a premium (extra income), but you also agree to sell your shares at a fixed price (the strike price) if the stock rises above that level before the option expires.
The term “covered” means you already own the shares, so if the option buyer chooses to exercise their right, you’re ready to deliver them.
For example, imagine you bought 100 shares of Company XYZ at $10, and the stock is now at $20. You might sell a call option with a $25 strike price and earn a premium — say $15 total for the contract. If the stock stays below $25, the option will expire worthless, and you keep both your shares and the premium. If the stock rises above $25, the option is likely to be exercised, and you’ll have to sell your shares at $25. Capping your upside, but still locking in a gain.
Covered calls are typically used by traders in a sideways or mildly bullish markets. They can generate income even during downturns by selling calls against your shares, but they offer no downside protection. This becomes risky in high IV environments, where traders sell calls for larger premiums but remain exposed to sharp drops. Without a hedge, losses can quickly outweigh the income earned.
Turn Your Protective Put into a Collar Strategy
While covered calls help generate income, they don’t protect you if the stock drops. That’s where a protective put comes in an options strategy. A protective put is an options strategy where you buy a put option against a stock you already own.
Imagine you own 100 shares of Tesla at $700 and want protection from short-term drops while staying long-term bullish. A protective put, say a $680 strike costing $15 per share — acts like insurance, limiting your downside. But at $1,500, it’s expensive.
To offset the cost, traders could sell a covered call at a $740 strike for a $10 premium, collecting $1,000. This reduces your net outlay while capping your upside. Together, the put and call form a more affordable hedge—protecting against big losses while generating income. It’s a balanced approach for traders navigating volatile markets without overspending on protection.
Ultimately, it’s up to the trader to adjust the strike prices based on how much protection they want versus how much upside they’re willing to give up.
Going In Depth to the Collar
The collar strategy offers more than just basic protection, it provides a strategic framework for traders who want to stay invested with clear boundaries around risk and reward. Here are four key advantages that make collars a powerful tool in a trader’s arsenal
Defined Exposure with Controlled Risk
First, a collar keeps you exposed to the stock you believe in, while placing a floor under your downside and a ceiling on your upside. This makes it ideal for situations where you're moderately bullish but want protection from unexpected dips. However, there's a trade-off: if the stock rallies past your call strike and you don’t manage the position, your shares may be called away. For some, this is an acceptable exit plan; for others, it could mean losing a core holding.
Ultimately, the collar is a strategic choice. It depends on what you want to achieve. While you may not capture the full upside like a regular investor holding the stock outright, you gain something arguably more valuable: control. Control over your risk, your outcomes, and how your portfolio responds in uncertain markets.
Dividend Collection Still Intact
Since you continue to hold the underlying shares, collars allow you to continue to capture dividends throughout the holding period. This makes the strategy attractive for income-focused investors who still want downside protection, especially during uncertain market cycles.
Flexibility in Structure
One of the collar’s most underrated strengths is its flexibility. You can tailor the strategy to your specific market outlook by adjusting the strike prices, time to expiration (DTE), and the strike width. Whether you're aiming for tighter protection, more upside, or cheaper cost, collars adapt to your risk appetite and directional bias.
Promotes Capital Efficiency and Emotional Discipline
Collars enforce a mechanical, rules-based approach to market fluctuations, which is critical for traders who tend to react emotionally during drawdowns. Rather than selling in panic or chasing gains, the collar sets clear boundaries and allows you to focus on process over prediction. It’s a strategy that encourages capital efficiency by managing risk proactively rather than reactively.
The Trader's Dilemma: Balancing Fear and Greed
You've just set up your collar: downside protected, upside capped. Now the market begins to move, not dramatically, but steadily creeping toward your call strike. You're watching, waiting. And that’s when the dilemma creeps in.
Do you stay patient and let the trade play out? Or do you chase more upside by adjusting your strikes, risking your protection?
Every trader contends with the emotions of fear and greed. These emotions don’t disappear with strategy, they simply change form. A covered call feels safe until the stock rallies. A protective put feels prudent until it expires worthless. And collars? They give you boundaries, but they don’t quiet the mind.
The disciplined trader navigates this by anchoring to process over outcome. Instead of asking "Did I leave money on the table?", they ask "Did I follow a repeatable process that matches my risk profile?" That’s how fear and greed are managed, not by eliminating them, but by making sure your trades serve a system greater than your feelings at the moment.
Ultimately, the trader's edge comes not from predicting direction, but from designing trades that reflect a clear intention: protect capital, grow steadily, and avoid emotional whiplash. It’s not always exciting, but it is sustainable.
submit your comment